Talk:Capturing Messages: Difference between revisions

From STRIDE Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(9 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Comments on “Wiki - Training Organization”
Comments on “Wiki - Training Organization”


RE: '''STRIDE is applied to both xUnit-style and system-level testing.'''
RE: '''STRIDE is applied to both xUnit-style and system-level testing.'''
Line 8: Line 8:
Tim - lets discuss.
Tim - lets discuss.


<br>
Comment on “Wiki - Getting Started” <br>
RE: '''You will be using the FrameworkSetup.pl script to setup packages for a Windows Framework.''' <br>
Perhaps should be “You will be using the FrameworkSetup.pl script to setup a Workspace with packages using a Windows Framework".


Comment on “Wiki - Getting Started”
<br>
'''You will be using the FrameworkSetup.pl script to setup packages for a Windows Framework.'''  
Inconsistency/error in “Wiki – Performing the Exercise"<br>
Perhaps should be “You will be using the FrameworkSetup.pl script to setup a Workspace with packages using a Windows Framework.
RE: '''One way Command Message with Payload By Value'''
*First bullet states “…with a payload passed by pointer and POOL memory usage.” – inconsistent with exercise title "By Value"
*“… and a payload consisting of a long field.” It’s not clear to me whether you’re asking for a payload of type long, or a payload of type structure with a single field of type long.  The use of the word field is a little confusing.


Comment on Instructions->Setup (here’s a real nitpickety item which I would probably ignore).
<br>
The instructions say Run the following from a command line (cmd.exe).
Inconsistency/error in “Wiki – Performing the Exercise”<br>
Then Navigate to the workspace location – which I took as from the command line as well, i.e. entering “cd c:\...
RE: '''One way Response Message with Payload By Pointer'''
Then Double click on the file CapturingMessages.ssw – which of course you can’t do from the command line.
*First bullet states “…with a payload passed by value.” – inconsistent with exercise title “By Pointer”
*“…and a payload consisting of an int field.” Again, is this to be a payload of type int, or a structure with a single field of type int.


Inconsistency/error in “Wiki – Performing the Exercise
<br>
One way Command Message with Payload By Value
Comment on “Wiki - Two Way Message with Response Payload”<br>
- First bullet states “…with a payload passed by pointer and POOL memory usage.”
RE: '''with an empty command payload'''
- “… and a payload consisting of a long field.” It’s not clear to me whether you’re asking for a payload of type long, or a payload of type structure with a single field of type long.  The use of the word field is a little confusing.
*Since we define a Stride message as having an optional payload, I think the word empty may be misleading here. I think '''''no''''' payload is more accurate.  
 
Inconsistency/error in “Wiki – Performing the Exercise”
One way Response Message with Payload By Pointer
- First bullet states “…with a payload passed by value.” – inconsistent with exercise title “By Pointer”
- “…and a payload consisting of an int field.” Again, is this to be a payload of type int, or a structure with a single field of type int.


Comment on “Wiki - Two Way Message with Response Payload”
<br>
re: with an empty command payload,
Inconsistency/error in “Wiki – Performing the Exercise”<br>
Since we define a Stride message as having an optional payload, I think the work empty may be misleading here.  I think no payload is more accurate.
RE: '''Broadcast Message with No Payload'''
*First bulled states “…with a payload passed by value” – inconsistent with exercise title “No Payload”


Inconsistency/error in “Wiki – Performing the Exercise”
<br>
Broadcast Message with No Payload
On first run, all tests failed due to incorrect message names used. Instruction was not explicit on what naming convention to use for the SMID definitions.
- First bulled states “…with a payload passed by value” – inconsistent with exercise title “No Payload”
 
<br>
After changing SMID names, 3 tests passed, 1 (TWO_WAY_MSG) failed. 
<br>
-- Try Again Incorrect instrumentation -- please try again (ID: 0cc2fe772eaf86fe53262099028b7ee2, BASIS: 2994ea239f033680c9df1db2d32e798e)

Latest revision as of 17:46, 31 March 2008

Comments on “Wiki - Training Organization”

RE: STRIDE is applied to both xUnit-style and system-level testing. Was surprised to see this statement. We usually tell customers that Stride can be used for all types of testing up to (pre) system test.

RE: If your primary interest is in integration or QA-style testing, proceed to the Test Scripts topic.

Tim - lets discuss.


Comment on “Wiki - Getting Started”
RE: You will be using the FrameworkSetup.pl script to setup packages for a Windows Framework.
Perhaps should be “You will be using the FrameworkSetup.pl script to setup a Workspace with packages using a Windows Framework".


Inconsistency/error in “Wiki – Performing the Exercise"
RE: One way Command Message with Payload By Value

  • First bullet states “…with a payload passed by pointer and POOL memory usage.” – inconsistent with exercise title "By Value"
  • “… and a payload consisting of a long field.” It’s not clear to me whether you’re asking for a payload of type long, or a payload of type structure with a single field of type long. The use of the word field is a little confusing.


Inconsistency/error in “Wiki – Performing the Exercise”
RE: One way Response Message with Payload By Pointer

  • First bullet states “…with a payload passed by value.” – inconsistent with exercise title “By Pointer”
  • “…and a payload consisting of an int field.” Again, is this to be a payload of type int, or a structure with a single field of type int.


Comment on “Wiki - Two Way Message with Response Payload”
RE: with an empty command payload

  • Since we define a Stride message as having an optional payload, I think the word empty may be misleading here. I think no payload is more accurate.


Inconsistency/error in “Wiki – Performing the Exercise”
RE: Broadcast Message with No Payload

  • First bulled states “…with a payload passed by value” – inconsistent with exercise title “No Payload”


On first run, all tests failed due to incorrect message names used. Instruction was not explicit on what naming convention to use for the SMID definitions.


After changing SMID names, 3 tests passed, 1 (TWO_WAY_MSG) failed.
-- Try Again Incorrect instrumentation -- please try again (ID: 0cc2fe772eaf86fe53262099028b7ee2, BASIS: 2994ea239f033680c9df1db2d32e798e)

Retrieved from "https://www.stridewiki.com/index.php?title=Talk:Capturing_Messages&oldid=4723"